Wanamaker & Carlough Funeral Home
WA
Wanamaker & Carlough Funeral Home
177 Route 59, Suffern, NY 10901 · (845) 357-0423
Part of Service Corporation InternationalPricing Verified
★★★★4.474 Google reviews

About Wanamaker & Carlough Funeral Home

Wanamaker & Carlough Funeral Home is a full-service funeral home in Suffern, NY operating under Service Corporation International (SCI), the largest corporate funeral home chain in the country — something families who prefer independent or locally owned providers may want to weigh. They offer a range of services including traditional burial and funeral arrangements, with staff who appear well-practiced in coordinating logistics such as church and cemetery scheduling, death certificates, and pre-planned arrangements. The home holds a 4.4-star rating across 74 Google reviews, and customers consistently highlight the professionalism and attentiveness of individual staff members, with several families returning to the funeral home after multiple losses. That said, two notable financial concerns appear in the reviews: one family reported difficulty obtaining accounting records for a prepaid arrangement going back nearly a decade, and another was sent to collections despite having provided payment — families considering pre-planning or those who want clear billing practices may want to ask detailed questions about financial policies before proceeding.
Pricing overview
Source: General Price List · Effective Jan 20, 2026
Use of Facilities and Staff16 items
Reception Room
$395
Alternative Vehicle
$395
Hearse
$795
Limousine
$745
Service vehicle
$250
Transfer to or from airport
$595
Transfer to or from crematory
$495
Casket and alternative containers: $95
$21,995
Outer burial containers/outer interment receptacles: $3,295
$5,495
Urns $65
$1,295
Casket Medallions $50
$295
Catered Receptions
From $295
Memorial Diamond $3,499
$75,000
Monument / Inscription Deposit
From $250
Monument Inscription
From $695
Professional Pallbearer (per person) $125
$150

Planning ahead? Lock in today’s prices.

Pre-need coverage lets you secure current funeral costs and spare your family from future financial decisions.

Compare providers →
Google Reviews
★★★★★Molly Scharf
a month ago

The team at Wannamaker and Carlough took great care of my mom. They were very professional and helped us through every single step. Coordination between the church and cemetery was all taken care of, as well as death certificates etc. The facility is very comfortable, clean, welcoming. They did a gr…

★★★★★Nadia Merhai
4 months ago

Michael was above and beyond courteous, professional and communicative. I believe all of their staff was as well.

★★★★★Elmire Zamis
a year ago

I just wanted to say thank you to Maureen at Wanamaker. My mom passed in 2018 and from that moment on Maureen and the staff at Wanamaker’s have supported my needs through the passing of my best friend, my aunt, and my dad. They handled my mom’s services exactly as she wanted. As for my other losses …

★★★★Joe Schneider
a year ago

The staff was very professional and they made the overall experience as good as possible. My utter disappointment regards their handling of the payment. Despite my providing a credit card to pay for the services, they deemed me to be delinquent and the account was provided to a debt collection servi…

★★★★Robin Menist
a year ago

My mother prepaid for her arrangements in 2006. She died April 2024. Her money was supposed to be put into an interest bearing account. We were not provided with any statements since 2015, at which time she had accumulated over $1,000 in interest. The funeral home was unwilling or unable to prov…

Quick facts
OwnershipService Corporation International
WebsiteVisit →
Phone(845) 357-0423
ServicesNot provided
HoursOpen 24 hours
Google reviews74 reviews →
Compare costs in Suffern

See how this provider’s pricing compares to all providers in Suffern.

View city costs →
Need help deciding?

Not sure which option is right? Browse all providers in the area.

Search nearby →