SH
Shirley Brothers Mortuaries Fishers-Castleton Chape
9900 N Allisonville Roa, Indianapolis, IN 46038 · (317) 841-7878
IndependentPricing Verified
★★★★★4.69 Google reviews

About Shirley Brothers Mortuaries Fishers-Castleton Chape

Shirley Brothers Mortuaries has served the Indianapolis area as an independently owned funeral home, which means families work with a locally rooted business rather than a national corporate chain. As a full-service funeral home, they are equipped to handle a range of arrangements including burial and cremation services. Direct cremation starts at $2,625, which sits at a mid-range to premium price point for the Indianapolis market. With a 4.6-star Google rating, customer sentiment appears positive, though the review volume of only 9 reviews is quite limited, making it difficult to draw firm conclusions about consistent strengths or concerns.
Compare direct cremationIndianapolis
Shirley Brothers Mor…
$2,625
★★★★★
This provider
Fountain Square Crem…
$695
Fountain Square Mort…
$800
★★★★
Grinsteiner Funeral …
$845
Pricing overview
Source: General Price List · Data as of Apr 2026
Direct cremation
All-inclusive package
$2,625
Direct cremation from
$2,625
Basic Services of Funeral Director and Staff1 items
Basic Services of the Director, Staff, and Overhead
$1,730
Embalming1 items
Embalming
$735
Use of Facilities and Staff4 items
Use of Facilities and Staff for Viewing/Visitation
$315
Use of Facilities and Staff for Funeral Ceremony
$345
Use of Facilities and Staff for Memorial Service
$345
Use of Equipment and Staff for Graveside Service
Contact
Transportation3 items
Transfer of Remains to Funeral Home (First Call)
$295
Use of a Funeral Coach (Hearse)
$225
Use of a Family Car (Limousine)
Contact
Forwarding of Remains1 items
Forwarding Remains to Another Funeral Home
Contact
Receiving Remains from Another Funeral Home1 items
Receiving Remains from Another Funeral Home
Contact
Direct Cremation1 items
Direct Cremation
$2,625
Immediate Burial1 items
Direct Burial
Contact

Planning ahead? Lock in today’s prices.

Pre-need coverage lets you secure current funeral costs and spare your family from future financial decisions.

Compare providers →
Google Reviews
★★★★★Alice Sobotka
a year ago

Jessica helped me complete my advanced planning project. She cared about my wishes and needs over trying to sell me services and products. I appreciated that. She offered information and options. She answered all my questions. She made a discussion I didn't want to have, easy and pleasant.

★★★★★Robert Williams
a year ago

Shirley Brothers recently handled the services for my wife. It was a difficult time but the staff were superb in all of their support. I especially want to thank Laura the funeral director. Thanks to her the services went smoothly. My family and I will call on them again when my time comes.

★★★★★Warren Back
5 years ago

The Shirley Brothers team did an outstanding job during a very difficult time. My father's passing was not planned and swift; therefore, I made a first call to Jim Shirley early in the morning and from that point forward, I had nothing to worry about. They immediately onboarded my father and setup…

★★★★★Jeanie Taylor
6 years ago

I have the utmost respect and gratitude for Shirley Brothers. In 2016 my son died unexpectedly. We did not have life insurance at the time and they were very kind, understanding and easy to work with. They worked with us and in 3 weeks we had the balance paid. They treated my family very well. I …

★★★★★R VanWynsberghe
7 years ago

We used Shirley Brothers for both of my grandparents in the early 2000's. In December of 2017 we lost our mom and there was no question as to who we would entrust with her care. Shirley Brothers was very professional and caring. Jim Shirley is the best! Thank you to all for you love and care.

Quick facts
OwnershipIndependent
Phone(317) 841-7878
ServicesNot provided
HoursNot provided
Google reviews9 reviews →
Compare costs in Indianapolis

See how this provider’s pricing compares to all providers in Indianapolis.

View city costs →
Need help deciding?

Not sure which option is right? Browse all providers in the area.

Search nearby →